Churches are an important resource in caring for America’s poor, but the job is too big for churches alone. With all the talk about healthcare and the nation’s deficit, I’ve seen more than one blog suggest that churches take over the responsibility for caring for the nation’s poor. While that is a noble goal, moving all government “safety net” programs to churches is a numerical impossibility. Let’s just take one example — the food stamp program, now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. The Cato Institute, a conservative think-tank, puts the food stamp program budget at about $75-billion dollars. But, let’s use a more conservative estimate from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. They estimate that 36-million Americans (1-in-8) receive what most of us call food stamps, or nutrition assistance. On average, each participant receives $133 per month, or about $1,596 per year. Okay, let’s do the math on those numbers: $1,596 x 36,000,000 = $57,426,000,000 or about $57.5 billion per year. That’s less than Cato estimates, but will serve our purposes just fine. The total number of congregations in America is generally estimated between 350,00 to 400,000. Let’s use the higher guesstimate of 400,000 churches of all denominations in the United States. The median size of these congregations is 90 in attendance each Sunday. Here’s where the numbers tell the story: For churches to take over the feeding of America’s poor, each church in America would have to feed 90 people each. That means that the average church would take on as many poor people as it currently has in attendance! But, even more difficult is the financial picture. If each church allocated $133 per month to feed each of the 90 people, the total yearly cost would be $143,640 per church per year. Most churches with 90 in attendance don’t have a total budget of $150K per year, much less a benevolence budget of that amount. Of course, this is only one program. The SNAP program is run through the US Department of Agriculture, but other programs Continue reading “Think Churches Can Feed America’s Poor?”
Jesus calls us to do the right thing at the right time as we seek to honor him with our lives.
The Right Thing At The Right Time
John 12:1-8 NIV
1Six days before the Passover, Jesus arrived at Bethany, where Lazarus lived, whom Jesus had raised from the dead. 2Here a dinner was given in Jesus’ honor. Martha served, while Lazarus was among those reclining at the table with him. 3Then Mary took about a pint of pure nard, an expensive perfume; she poured it on Jesus’ feet and wiped his feet with her hair. And the house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume.
4But one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, who was later to betray him, objected, 5″Why wasn’t this perfume sold and the money given to the poor? It was worth a year’s wages.” 6He did not say this because he cared about the poor but because he was a thief; as keeper of the money bag, he used to help himself to what was put into it.
7″Leave her alone,” Jesus replied. ” It was intended that she should save this perfume for the day of my burial. 8You will always have the poor among you, but you will not always have me.”
It’s All A Matter of Timing
Several years ago, friends of ours told this story about the pastor they served with. This pastor was known for being rather abrupt, and was not the most subtle in conversation. During a wedding at their church, the pastor was officiating, of course. When the time came for the vows, the groom was rather nervous, as many grooms are.
The pastor began to read the vows —
“Do you, John, take Mary for your wife…”
At which point, the anxious groom interrupted by saying “I do.” The pastor, obviously not finished with the entire reading of the vows, looked at him and said, “Not yet!”
The pastor started again, “And do you promise before God and these witnesses to to love her….”
Again, the groom jumped the gun, “I do.”
And again the pastor replied, “Not yet!”
Well this went on a couple more times until finally the pastor got to the last question —
“…and forsaking all others to keep thee only unto her so long as you both shall live?”
He paused and looked at the groom, who by now was so gun shy that he didn’t dare say a word.
After what seemed like an eternity, the pastor finally turned to him and said, “Now!”
I thought we had heard it all when the chairman of Goldman-Sachs testified that they were “doing God’s work.” Apparently, that altruistic assertion went so well that Verizon has picked up the refrain.
In a response to the FTC’s request for justification for their high fees, Verizon claims their higher early termination fees “help the poor by making it more affordable for them to access the mobile internet,” according to Wired.com.
Of course, both companies made billions of dollars this year. Apparently doing God’s work pays very well.
A new study reveals a specific link between luxury goods and selfishness. Two experiments showed that “exposure to luxury led people to think more about themselves than others,” according to a Harvard Business School paper.
Professor Roy Y. J. Chua and Xi Zou conducted two experiments in which one group of participants was exposed to pictures of luxury goods such as watches and shoes, and the other group was shown pictures of watches and shoes that were not luxury brands. After participants identified characteristics of the goods, they were then asked to take an unrelated survey about decision-making. Those exposed to luxury goods were significantly more likely to act in their own self-interest, even at the expense or harm of others.
In a second experiment, those exposed to luxury goods were less able to identify words that expressed positive social actions, than those who were only exposed to non-luxury goods. In other words, the cognition, or thought process, of those exposed to luxury goods tended to be self-centered, and self-interested with less regard for others.
All of this might explain why people like Tiger Woods make such absurdly self-centered choices. Tiger owns both a luxury yacht and private jet, not to mention the Cadillac Escalade he just wrecked, or the mansions he owns, and so on. This might also explain why the head of Goldman Sachs described banks, including his, as “doing God’s work.” Luxury tends to blind us to the needs of others, and bias us toward our own self-interest.
The Harvard Business article is playfully titled, “The Devil Wears Prada?” — an apparent play on the book and movie by the same name, only without the question mark.
So, when Jesus said, “Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat or drink; or about your body, what you will wear” he was telling us how to order our lives so that we have the basic necessities of life, but also are concerned that others have them too. It also puts the “prosperity gospel” (I hate to write those words together) in a new light. Preachers who drive around in luxury cars, fly in private jets, and tell their flocks how they can get ahead, may be creating the next generation of self-centered church members. Not that we haven’t seen that before, but this time we have proof that the more you have, the less concern you have for others. Something to think about during the Christmas season.
More world citizens and more Americans go hungry each day than ever before in the history of the world. One billion people out of the 6-billion who inhabit the earth, do not have enough to eat. Almost 17% of the world’s population — 1-in-6 people in other words — are undernourished or malnourished.
In the United States of America, the numbers are no better: 16%, or 49-million Americans do not have access to adequate food. Again, 1-in-6 in the most affluent country in the world go hungry.
The reasons for this record rise in world hunger lie in the global economic crisis coupled with the rising cost of food. Food costs worldwide have increased 24% in just 4-years. Civil unrest has followed the increasing cost of food and threatens to be the next global catastrophe.
But, here’s the interesting part: In a newly-released Pew Forum survey, a majority of Americans prefer that religious groups feed the hungry and homeless. Faith-based programs remain popular with the American public, and 52% said faith-based organizations are best able to feed the hungry. Interestingly, those numbers are actually up from 8 years ago when the same questions were asked.
But are faith-based groups, churches included, doing what we can to feed people? If 1-in-6 persons are hungry in America and the world, they should no longer be invisible to us. Unfortunately, the hungry are disproportionately poor, minority, and marginalized by society. They remain invisible to a vast majority of Christians because our paths do not cross, our children do not go to the same schools, and our social calendars do not coincide.
But this is a golden opportunity for faith-based groups to step up and fulfill the vision that America has for us. If we as churches can do what our culture thinks we ought to do, which includes feeding hungry people, then we might find our place again in our own culture. With church attendance continuing its 50-year decline from a high of 40% to today’s 17.5%, we need to reclaim our place in the world.
Wouldn’t it be interesting if the church reclaimed its place in culture by finding its place among the poor? Of course, that’s what Jesus did. And he fed them, too.
Materialism: Why Do We Have So Much Stuff?
18A certain ruler asked him, “Good teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?”
19“Why do you call me good?” Jesus answered. “No one is good—except God alone. 20You know the commandments: ‘Do not commit adultery, do not murder, do not steal, do not give false testimony, honor your father and mother.'”
21“All these I have kept since I was a boy,” he said.
22When Jesus heard this, he said to him, “You still lack one thing. Sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.”
23When he heard this, he became very sad, because he was a man of great wealth. 24Jesus looked at him and said, “How hard it is for the rich to enter the kingdom of God! 25Indeed, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God.”
26Those who heard this asked, “Who then can be saved?”
27Jesus replied, “What is impossible with men is possible with God.”
28Peter said to him, “We have left all we had to follow you!”
29“I tell you the truth,” Jesus said to them, “no one who has left home or wife or brothers or parents or children for the sake of the kingdom of God 30will fail to receive many times as much in this age and, in the age to come, eternal life.”
Has Jesus Lost His Mind?
Okay, imagine you live in the first century and you pastor a new church in Jerusalem. So far the only members you have attracted to your congregation are 12 guys who, to say the least, are not the cream of the crop. Several of them are fishermen, which is a smelly, messy business. One is a tax collector, or rather former tax collector, because he left a fine source of income to follow you. One is a domestic terrorist, Simon the Zealot, and he’s on the “no fly” list at the Judean Department of Homeland Security. One of them, Judas, is a self-taught accountant — at least that’s the story he told every one. Actually, all of these men, all 12 of them, are technically unemployed. They all left their jobs — fishing nets, tax collection booth, accounting, what have you — to follow you. Which is great, except the offerings have been down for some time now.
So, one day a really nice looking, extremely well-dressed young man comes up to you. He addresses you in polite and polished Aramaic, not the slanguage of the fishing village that most of your guys speak. And, he graciously calls you “good master.”
But, it’s his sincerity in asking his question that really gets to you. “What must I do to obtain eternal life?” So, this is a serious young man, too.
Here is a prime candidate for discipleship. He’s rich, young, and he’s a leader. Luke calls him a “certain ruler,” which probably meant he led a synagogue or was a leading member of a religious party with authority over others. In any event, he’s the best looking, wealthiest, and most articulate person who has questioned you.
That’s the situation that Jesus found himself in. Mark’s Gospel says everything that Luke’s does, plus it adds that this man “ran up to Jesus and fell on his knees before him.” So, the young man was not only rich, and powerful, but urgently seeking some answers to his spiritual questions.
Jesus replies by saying, “You know the commandments,” and Jesus begins to recite them:
- Do not commit adultery,
- do not murder,
- do not steal,
- do not give false testimony,
- honor your father and mother.
Now, what do you notice about this list of commandments that Jesus quotes? Well, first, these aren’t all the commandments. Jesus only quotes 5 here. There are 5 more, which is why the original list is called the Ten Commandments. But, why these five?
You might remember the Ten Commandments, but if not, let me give you a quick run-down from Exodus 20. Here they all are:
1. You shall have no other gods before me.
2. You shall not make for yourself an idol…
3. You shall not misuse the name of the LORD your God..
4. Remember the Sabbath day by keeping it holy.
5. Honor your father and your mother…
6. You shall not murder.
7. You shall not commit adultery.
8. You shall not steal.
9. You shall not give false testimony against your neighbor.
10. You shall not covet…
The first 4 commandments have to do with our relationship with God, and the next 6 have to do with how we treat others. Jesus totally skips over the first 4, and goes right to numbers 5-9, not in the exact order, but he gets them all in there.
Isn’t that interesting? Wouldn’t you, if someone asked you how to obtain eternal life, wouldn’t you start with stuff about God, especially the first 4 commandments — no other Gods, no idols, no taking God’s name in vain, and keep God’s day holy. I would, but Jesus doesn’t.
Jesus, instead, focuses the young man’s attention on 5 of the 6 commandments that are pretty straight-forward, and that deal with how you relate to other people.
The young ruler’s answer is — I’ve done all that since I was a kid. He had honored his father and mother, hadn’t killed anybody, hadn’t committed adultery (obviously he was not the governor of South Carolina), hadn’t stolen anything (after all he was rich), and hadn’t lied in court.
Now, Jesus probably knew that he was a good guy, and that this was going to be his answer.
Because then Jesus says, “But you’re missing one thing.”
At this point, all eyes and ears are on Jesus. The rich young ruler especially is completely captivated. And I am sure the look on his face is a mixture of both relief and expectancy.
He’s probably thinking at this point — “Okay, only one thing, that’s good. Just one more thing, and I’ve got this in the bag.”
Then, Jesus says, “Sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.”
Silence. Dead still. Nobody moves. They’re all in shock, not the least of which is the rich young ruler.
The Bible says “When he heard this, he became very sad, because he was a man of great wealth.”
The young man turns his back on Jesus and walks away. End of story. But not quite.
Because the disciples are stunned. “If this guy can’t make it, who can?” they ask Jesus? Why did they ask that? Because first, he was a righteous man. He took the law seriously and thought he kept it. Jews in the first century did not have our false humility about “nobody can live up to God’s law.” They fully expected to keep the law, and to do so developed thousands of rules to explain exactly what the law meant, and how far you could go and still be “keeping the law.”
Of course, Jesus blew all that nonsense away in the Sermon on the Mount, when he said over and over, “You have heard it has been said…but I say unto you.” And he reimagined what it meant to keep and break the law of God. But, that’s a sermon for another day.
But, even more than the young man’s righteousness, was his wealth. If a person was wealthy, others assumed God’s favor on him. God blessed him with wealth, therefore God smiled on him. He was one of God’s favorites, and his wealth was the sign of God’s blessing.
Now we know that wealth is not necessarily a sign of God’s favor, but there are still thousands of folks who today think so. The so-called “Prosperity Gospel” movement is built on the idea that God will bless you materially, if you do certain things. Most of those things involve sending money to your local television evangelist, who promises you that your “seed faith” sown in trust will reap you a great material harvest. So, the idea that lots of money is a sign of God’s blessing is still with us.
The disciples are stunned. How can anybody be saved if those whom God has blessed can’t be? Jesus reply, “What is impossible with men is possible with God.”
Then, Peter sees an opportunity to score some points, and he blurts out, “We have left everything to follow you!” In other words, “Hey, Jesus, look at us — we’ve left everything just like you told the rich guy to do. Pretty good, huh?” Jesus is not impressed, and doesn’t commend Peter, but he does say that “no one who has left home or wife or brothers or parents or children for the sake of the kingdom of God will fail to receive many times as much in this age and, in the age to come, eternal life.” So, you are going to be rewarded in this life and in the life to come no matter what you give up.
But, back to our story.
If We Were Jesus
If we were Jesus, here’s how this conversation would have gone:
Rich young ruler: What must I do to obtain eternal life?
Us: Keep the commandments.
RYR: I’ve done that since I was a kid.
Us: Great! Sounds like you’re our kind of people. By the way, that’s a stunning tie you have on? Did you get that at Brooks Brothers?
RYR: Why yes I did. If you like it, I could get you one. They’re only a $100 each, so not really expensive. As a matter of fact, take this one, and I’ll get another one later.
Us: Well, thanks. Say, let me tell you about our plans to build the largest synagogue in the world. God has given me a great vision for reaching people, and you can play a big part in that. Here’s a donor card. Could I put you down for a lifetime membership for only $10,000. Of course, for just $5,000 more you could be in the Pastor’s Circle, a very special group of those who support the ministry.
RYR: And that will get me eternal life?
Us: Actually, no, but we can talk about that later. Of course, God will be very pleased with you if you’re a good steward of the things he’s blessed you with. Could I put you down for a gift today? Our books close on June 30, so you’ve only got a couple of days left. Oh, of course, it’s all tax-deductible.
RYR: Well, I was really looking for eternal life today, but sure, why not. Maybe this is a first step in the right direction.
Us: I’m sure it is.
Okay, you get the point. If we were Jesus, we would not have told this guy to sell all he had. Or if we had, we certainly would not have told him to give it to the poor.
Have you ever thought about how he would give it to the poor? Would he had out 100-drachma coins on the street? Would he build a new homeless shelter in downtown Jerusalem? Would he have people sign up, and make sure they qualified by filling out a lot of paperwork? How would he actually give this money away to the poor?
And if he gave all his money away, he would still be young, but would he be a ruler? Probably not. Why, because money is power. Always has been, always will be. The rich young ruler knows that money is power, and asks “how can I obtain (get, purchase, acquire) eternal life.” He’s been able to parlay his wealth into position and prestige, now perhaps it will help him get a guaranteed ticket on the Heaven Express.
The Way We Handle Money Matters
I’ve heard preachers say, “Did Jesus really mean for him to sell everything he had and give it to the poor? Absolutely not, Jesus already knew he wouldn’t and so this was the young man’s ultimate test.”
And here’s where I’m going to disagree with those preachers. Jesus usually meant what he said. I think he meant for the rich young ruler to sell everything he had to follow Jesus. After all, why would he need it.
- Jesus had already told his disciples that the birds have nests and the foxes have holes, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.
- He had taught the disciples to pray “Give us this day our daily bread” reminding them of God’s feeding the nation of Israel with manna while they were on their 40-year journey to the Promised Land.
- Jesus had shown them the power of God to provide by feeding 5,000 people with a boy’s lunch.
- Jesus had sent them out 2-by-2 and commanded them to take nothing with them, and the disciples returned amazed at how God had provided.
- Jesus had already told them to give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.
- Jesus had healed people for free, fed people for free, cast out demons for free, and preached to the crowd for free. In God’s economy, God is the source of all supply whatever the need.
Suppose Jesus were to ask us, “Sell this church and give the money to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven.”
Our insurance company tells us the buildings and furnishings are worth about $3-million. Not a small sum, even in today’s economy. We could do that.
I read recently of a church in California that abandoned plans to build a multi-million dollar building and instead began to meet in homes. All the money they were going to spend on building and maintenance they decided to give to feed people, clothe people, and help people.
The decisions we make about money cannot be hidden under the “we’re doing this for God” excuse. God doesn’t need our money or our buildings or our wealth to accomplish his purposes. God needs our obedience.
The Current State of Our Economy
According to the American Almanac, even though the United States has only 5% of the world’s population, we consume 26% of the world’s energy. Well, of course, we do. We have to in order to run our air conditioners, our washers and dryers, our TVs, our DVD players, our computers, our hot water heaters, our microwaves, our refrigerators and freezers, our electric lights, our stereos, our cell phone chargers, our answering machines, our electric razors, hairdryers, curling irons, treadmills, and soon our electric cars.
So, our economic status separates us from the rest of the world. Because we use 26% of the world’s energy, we are leaving only 74% of the world’s energy to the remaining 95% of the world’s population.
And, do you know what the developing world tells us when we say to them, “Wow, we’ve made a mess of this planet, let’s all cut back and conserve energy.”
They say to us, “We want the same thing you have. No fair cutting off the power before we get to have our own cars, microwaves, TVs, computers and so on.” In other words, they want to be just like us.
I was in Shanghai, China very close to Christmas one year, and I was amazed. The Chinese malls and shopping districts were decorated for Xmas. Santa Claus was pictured, presents were wrapped, Christmas songs like “Rudolph the Rednose Reindeer” played over the PA systems. It was just like being in the US during the Christmas shopping spree. Of course, no Jesus, but hey, they had everything else!
The United Nations last week announced that now over 1-billion people are officially listed as being hungry, not having enough to eat. 1-billion, while we battle obesity here in the United States. Forgive another China story, but Americans eat such large servings, Dan Ryan’s restaurant in Hong Kong has a disclaimer that says, “We serve American portions.” Translation: you’re going to get a lot of food!
The Church World is No Different
But, you might say, those are all stories and statistics of the non-Christian world. Unfortunately, the church world is no different. Michael Spencer quotes the Charlotte World as saying,
As they say in the ginsu knife commercial, “But, wait, there’s more!” Beliefnet, which claims to be the world’s largest spirituality site, is owned by Rupert Murdoch’s NewsCorp. Zondervan, one of the oldest and largest evangelical publishers, is owned by Harper/Collins, which is owned by Rupert Murdoch’s NewsCorp. Beginning to see a pattern here? Obviously, Rupert Murdoch, an Australian billionaire and media mogul, believes there is big money to be made from the Christian market.
But suppose we quit buying “Jesus Junk” as Michael Spencer calls it. That would free up $4.5-billion annually for hunger relief, education, medical missions, and anything else you could think of.
Suppose our call to “sell all you have” just means quit buying useless stuff, even if it’s Christian useless stuff?
Economics divides the world into haves and have-nots, and the have-nots are usually not courted by our churches because they can’t contribute financially to the church budget. Years ago, I heard Rick Warren talk about the type of church member that Saddleback Church went after. Warren called him, “Saddleback Sam” and his complete demographic included the following profile:
I am happy to tell you that since Rick Warren’s runaway bestseller, The Purpose Driven Life, Warren has turned his attention to the world’s poor, particularly those with HIV/Aids. But “Saddleback Sam” is the kind of person almost every church wants — young, rich, professional. A modern day rich young ruler.
But are we telling these rich young rulers that Jesus says to sell everything, give it to the poor, and follow him? Nope, we’re asking them to give to our budgets, our mission programs, and to buy our Christian products. In short, we who follow Jesus have forgotten that God’s economy is not the world’s, and that Jesus came to make all things new, including how we handle possessions and money.
We who follow Jesus must model a different economic reality for the world to see. An economy that is based on trust in God, care for God’s children and creation, and a new sense of what is enough in light of the need of the world. An economy where there is an abundance of resources, and those resources are shared with others so that no one is lacking.
Our new economy must reach out to those who struggle and bring them along with us. Our new economy must build lives, not monuments to our own pride. Our new model must put possessions in proper perspective, and we must see the “stuff of our lives” not as material to be hoarded, but as a blessing to be shared.
Our new model must reflect our belief that whoever gives up “home or wife or brothers or parents or children for the sake of the kingdom of God will not fail to receive many times as much in this age and, in the age to come, eternal life.”
Today the stock market fell another 500 points. Iceland may go bankrupt, NPR reported today. Euro-countries are aligning their financial strategies so they speak with one economic voice. Government leaders are already talking about more federal dollars, in addition to the $700-billion just voted by Congress. And the bad news keeps coming. Churches, I pointed out yesterday, will feel the fallout from this economic meltdown. But, is there an upside? Not to trivialize the situation, but yes, I think there is an upside for churches in this economic turndown.
- Churches will be forced to focus. We’re cutting our church budget this year by about 10%. To do that, we have to look carefully at what is really important to our mission and message. That kind of attention and discipline will make us more effective in ministry.
- People will turn to churches for help. Plan now for ways to help those who need money for utilities, food to feed their families, and warm coats for the cold winter. This preparation must go beyond the typical food pantry, clothes closet that most churches have, although those can be a good starting point.
- Communities will pull together. When Katrina hit, our church called together the entire community to discuss ways we might help. People want to help others, and churches can unite the community in that effort.
- Church can demonstrate an alternative to the consumer society. If church is an alternative community living out the message of Christ, what better example is there than living out an alternative to the current consumerist approach that drives the global economy. Generosity, hospitality, sharing, sacrificing, giving, saving, stewardship of resources are all attributes of a Christian lifestyle.